“He Thinks He Has To Lead Alone… Because His Father Had To”

“He thinks he has to lead alone… because his father had to”

That scene left me somewhat sour when I first saw it, and it still does. Valka is trying to give Astrid advice as she was the woman married to the Chief. As Chieftess one would assume Valka had responsibilities as well, and her first duty was to her husband.

But like, I don’t think Valka had the right to be coaching Astrid? First of all, the reason Stoick was left alone was because of YOU, Valka. Hiccup has this impression of his father because Valka was never there. Hiccup figures that if his father, who would always be mourning the death of his wife, could do it, so could he. And honestly, I think Hiccup doesn’t like to mess up, not necessarily that he thinks he has to lead alone. He can be in his head sometimes, but we’ve seen him incorporate other’s ideas (in RTTE which was totally not taken into account in THW) and I don’t think Hiccup has ever admitted that he thinks he has to lead alone anyway. So I’m not sure why Valka thinks she’s right. Unless it was said offscreen, but what would that matter if the audience didn’t see it.

The movie lacked any real scenes between Valka and Hiccup imo.

And then Valka suggests Astrid console him, as though Valka knows Hiccup all that well. I know she means well, and had known Hiccup for a year, but I don’t think she had the right to play parent when he’s a grown adult who’s leading the village.

I get Valka is the voice of reason like Stoick was to Hiccup and Astrid (we see that mainly in RTTE between him and Astrid), but personally, she didn’t earn the right to give advice regarding the son she left behind for twenty years.

You wanna play wise parent now? Too late.

Again, I know she means well and is able to recognize her husband’s challenges in her son, but I just think the conversation was unnecessary. Astrid already KNOWS what to do with Hiccup. Astrid’s really the only person that can get Hiccup to spill and he’s always honest with her. Astrid knows how to handle him, and she knows how to communicate. Heck, Astrid knows Hiccup better than Valka does.

I’m sure the writers must’ve realized too late that there weren’t any scenes between Valka and Astrid (which sucks because I feel like Astrid would hold some resentment towards her on Hiccup’s behalf, and that would’ve been an interesting conversation) and they needed to come up with a scene. I don’t see Valka as wise as Stoick was. She’s cool yeah, and this post wasn’t made to bash her, but her character overall was just not handled right from the start.

More Posts from Apersonnamedel and Others

3 months ago

Massive fan of a lot of rtte just being Hiccup giving people unimpressed looks

5 months ago
So Apparently Not Everyone Had Noticed This, But… 
So Apparently Not Everyone Had Noticed This, But… 
So Apparently Not Everyone Had Noticed This, But… 
So Apparently Not Everyone Had Noticed This, But… 

So apparently not everyone had noticed this, but… 

Hiccup is left-handed (this is the part pretty much everyone knows), BUT he actually tries to use his right hand sometimes when trying to “fit in” with the others, when he’s trying to act in a “traditional” way (and usually failing). 

The most prominent instance of this, I think, is the part where he finds Toothless tangled in the bola-ropes in the forests, and plans to kill him. During the “I’m going to cut out your heart…”/“I’m a VIKING!” speech, he’s holding the knife right'handedly. 

But then he can’t do it, because he’s not like everyone else, so instead he cuts the ropes to let Toothless free… And he uses his left hand to cut those ropes. 

He’s also seen holding weapons (or, well, trying to) right-handedly in dragon training. 

But yeah he’s clearly left-handed; he writes and draws with the left hand, he uses his left to do metalwork and so on and so forth. 

He’s fundamentally different from everyone else, and while the filmmakers never brought up Hiccup’s handedness the way the books did, they did something a bit more subtle with it. When Hiccup is doing something different, something he’s good at, he’s using his left hand, and that’s when he succeeds at stuff. He released Toothless from those ropes left-handedly. He made that artificial tailfin for Toothless left-handedly. He does things others don’t do, and that way, he makes new discoveries others never did before. 

It’s when he tries to be just like everyone else when things don’t work out for him. And the filmmakers subtly made him use his right hand during many of those moments. It’s what everyone else is doing, and they seem to succeed at it without too much trouble, but Hiccup isn’t just like them, so when he tries, he fails. 

And when we consider the whole left tailfin/leg thing between Hiccup and Toothless and how that becomes a fundamental part of their relationship…symbiosis…thing, it might sort of connect the symbolism to that as well (but I’ll have to think more about that before I could possibly make a sensible post out of it.)

3 weeks ago

I love the fact that the more you look and analyze Stan’s character more and more, the more tragic and sad it becomes.

Going from silly comedy man to haha im sobbing is not easy.

I’ve been reversed pranked and I am not enjoying it


Tags
2 months ago
Watching Blue Eye Samurai, One Of The Most Criminally Underrated And Depressingly Under-blogged Anime

watching blue eye samurai, one of the most criminally underrated and depressingly under-blogged anime of all time, again. t’s such an insanely gorgeously animated and cleverly crafted story. the protagonist being a woman pretending to be male isn’t told in a disney-fied “girlboss” way, she’s a fully fleshed out character. the series follows heavy themes of revenge, otherness in being biracial in edo period, the position of women in this time, and even disability. and it’s so fucking good and raw and incredible, this is extremely well done storytelling created by a woman. so not only do you get to watch a spectacular series, it’s finally a story that doesn’t feel like it’s trying to punch you in the face with artificial care for diversity. it’s so refreshing. y’all are truly missing out.

Watching Blue Eye Samurai, One Of The Most Criminally Underrated And Depressingly Under-blogged Anime
3 months ago
I May Have Forgotten While Writing My Princess Bride AU Fanfiction

I may have forgotten while writing my princess bride AU fanfiction


Tags
1 month ago

katniss: how do you think haymitch won the games?

peeta: he outsmarted the others

haymitch in his games: drinks poison water, falls asleep in a blueberry patch without attempting to cover his tracks, tries to pet a bunny during the countdown, makes an alarming number of bunny-related decisions in general

4 months ago
Reminder For When He “saves” It. He Was The One Who Wanted This, And Now He Gets To Be The Hero And

Reminder for when he “saves” it. He was the one who wanted this, and now he gets to be the hero and win favour with young constituents. Don’t give him the credit for fixing his own problem.


Tags
4 months ago

Man I love HTTYD


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • i-speak-for-the-star-child
    i-speak-for-the-star-child liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • ollievion
    ollievion liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • xxkittwonnxx
    xxkittwonnxx reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • teal-blue-genesis
    teal-blue-genesis liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • purgatoryorbust
    purgatoryorbust liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • avoidace
    avoidace liked this · 1 month ago
  • starstudded783
    starstudded783 liked this · 1 month ago
  • randomblabdom
    randomblabdom liked this · 1 month ago
  • vb8991
    vb8991 liked this · 1 month ago
  • valinlikesorangejuice
    valinlikesorangejuice liked this · 1 month ago
  • clarascrabarmy
    clarascrabarmy liked this · 1 month ago
  • pinay12204
    pinay12204 liked this · 1 month ago
  • leave-me-a-coin666
    leave-me-a-coin666 liked this · 1 month ago
  • nokohanne
    nokohanne liked this · 1 month ago
  • portraitofadyke
    portraitofadyke liked this · 1 month ago
  • fake-geek-girl-616
    fake-geek-girl-616 liked this · 1 month ago
  • nothingbutstardust12
    nothingbutstardust12 liked this · 1 month ago
  • katharina698
    katharina698 liked this · 2 months ago
  • undeadyetdying
    undeadyetdying liked this · 2 months ago
  • issacfootfungus
    issacfootfungus liked this · 3 months ago
  • konfetttii
    konfetttii liked this · 3 months ago
  • sailingalbatross
    sailingalbatross liked this · 3 months ago
  • chirdswitharms
    chirdswitharms liked this · 3 months ago
  • localcryptid27
    localcryptid27 reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • localcryptid27
    localcryptid27 liked this · 3 months ago
  • beletteaubeurre
    beletteaubeurre liked this · 3 months ago
  • skyflyer24
    skyflyer24 liked this · 3 months ago
  • henkdeplank
    henkdeplank reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • lunanightriderofthecove
    lunanightriderofthecove liked this · 3 months ago
  • nori-no-name
    nori-no-name liked this · 3 months ago
  • kyuubinu
    kyuubinu liked this · 3 months ago
  • primroseprime2019
    primroseprime2019 liked this · 3 months ago
  • ourislandkingdom
    ourislandkingdom liked this · 3 months ago
  • the-archivist-14
    the-archivist-14 reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • the-archivist-14
    the-archivist-14 liked this · 3 months ago
  • roosterpoison
    roosterpoison reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • roosterpoison
    roosterpoison liked this · 3 months ago
  • names-nameless
    names-nameless reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • names-nameless
    names-nameless liked this · 3 months ago
  • graevelabyss
    graevelabyss liked this · 3 months ago
  • frosti-moon
    frosti-moon liked this · 3 months ago
  • dragonsinboston
    dragonsinboston reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • bwiston
    bwiston liked this · 3 months ago
  • cachi-787
    cachi-787 liked this · 3 months ago
  • thesentientburgersqueaks
    thesentientburgersqueaks liked this · 3 months ago
  • xfranzi
    xfranzi liked this · 3 months ago
  • grey-loves-vikings
    grey-loves-vikings liked this · 3 months ago
  • justsomeimbicel
    justsomeimbicel liked this · 3 months ago

They/themLikes consuming media, art, writing, analysis, and my Ocs.I eat children for breakfast :3

201 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags