"Battles Are Ugly When Women Fight" =/= "women Shouldn't Fight Ever." Jack Never Said That. In Narnia,

"Battles are ugly when women fight" =/= "women shouldn't fight ever." Jack never said that. In Narnia, women demonstrably do fight in battles. Case in point: Lucy in HHB, Jill in LB.

You can judge the moral value of any society based on how it treats its most vulnerable members: women, children, minorities. Women are inherently vulnerable in wartime. Any battle in which women must fight is de facto extremely ugly, and it reflects very poorly on the society that placed them in that position.

That said, "Women feel that they must fight in the battle because the situation is so desperate/the culture fails to recognize their vulnerability/the culture actively exploits them" is entirely different than "adult women choose to fight as a matter of calling and do so in culturally appropriate ways." There's a very good reason why most modern democratic nations allow women to enlist, but don't include women in their drafts.

Father Christmas says "battles are ugly when women fight" specifically to clarify that Susan and Lucy don't have to go into battle against the Witch even though he's arming them. He's saying, "That's not your job; Narnia won't put its women in positions where they must fight." This is not a remotely misogynist statement; it's saying that a noble society has a responsibility to care for women during wartime. Which. Yes.

More Posts from Tarume and Others

3 years ago

skeletons

1 year ago

To believe in something beyond objective reality is a religion. You cannot force people to believe your religion.

Yes, Let's Talk About "your" Pronouns For A Moment, Because I Have Some Thoughts On The Matter...

Yes, let's talk about "your" pronouns for a moment, because I have some thoughts on the matter...

What's that? Oh, silly me. By "let's talk about," what you actually mean is "unquestioningly comply with my demands."

Be that as it may, "we" - which is to say, "I" - am going to talk about it regardless.

Let's analyze this for a moment.

She gives the game away right up front: blue heart is for boys, pink heart is for girls. This ideology is based on stereotypes. If you still doubt this, I don't know what else to show you to convince you.

Secondly, her "gender" isn't a profound knowledge of personal identity, because it changes faster than the weather. I'm not even sure it's her personality, because anyone whose personality changes that rapidly and that wildly has some kind of severe disorder. What she's calling "gender" seems to be nothing but her mood.

Thirdly, and I keep having to repeat this, if your "gender" requires others to participate, then it's not a "deeply personal sense of self." Just like your faith cannot be "a personal relationship with Jesus" if everybody else has to pray or refrain from pointing out the flaws in the bible. "Gender is a social construct" means that your "gender" only "exists" to the extent people play along. People are sick of being bullied into pretending for narcissists.

More importantly, you don't get to make others participate and then deny them any say or input. You can't give people an obligation with no authority, because if you think you can, then others can give you an obligation with no authority.

And you don't get to make others responsible for your mental wellbeing, to carry the burden you cannot or will not, and then get angry when they don't meet your standards or decline the obligation at all. You are responsible for you. Trying to make other people responsible for your emotions or mental state is psychotic. Xians insist that humans - and particularly children - are responsible for keeping their god happy, evidently because he cannot do it himself. You're just as much of an immature psychopath. We are not responsible for keeping you from bursting like a fragile soap bubble.

You can have a personal, unquestionable conviction, or you can have a matter of public interest and discussion. As soon as you insist others participate, you forfeit the right to cordon your beliefs off from scrutiny. If you want your beliefs to go unmolested, then keep them to yourself.

If it's nobody else's business, don't make it other people's business. You can't claim your "gender" is nobody else's business, nobody else gets a say, and then insist it is their business to comply with these demands and prop the whole delusion up.

Private concern or public interest. Choose one.

Fourthly, anyone who comes up with rules like this is a sociopath who is trying to control, manipulate and trap others. Since third-person pronouns are used primarily when someone is not present, when referring to an individual when talking to others, this is a form of authoritarian thought-control. You do not get to dictate how others must see you or think of you. They get to decide for themselves what they think of you, regardless of whether or not you like it, and it's none of your business. And if your sense of self is so flimsy that you must coerce them to conform their view of you to your own view of yourself, then you have bigger problems than "your" pronouns.

When she walks into room, people stiffen because they have to talk like idiots around her - and that's part of the appeal. She wants to be "misgendered," because who is she if she's not a marginalized victim and the center of attention? That's the trick: either you comply, and she wins, or you refuse, and she gets to pretend to be a victim and she wins. Nobody's obliged to pay attention to these insane, imaginary rules, much less play along. When she's already gamed it to win no matter what, the only way for you to win is to retain your integrity and self-respect and tell the truth.

And finally, you do not have pronouns. The pronouns belong to the language, in this case, English. The English language has pronouns for you. You don't have your own pronouns any more than you have your own conjugations or your own adjectives. Other languages, such as German, French, Spanish, Italian, Russian, Chinese and Japanese, have their own structures, and they're not for you to "fix" with your stupid activism.

And yes, languages change. They evolve through common usage and common acceptance, not through narcissists performing blunt-force creationism enforced with emotional manipulation and vilification.

She's an average, unremarkable girl who's found a socially acceptable way to control other people and pretend to be interesting.

Yes, Let's Talk About "your" Pronouns For A Moment, Because I Have Some Thoughts On The Matter...

My adjectives are amazing/brilliant/impressive.

Misadjectiving is hate. #BeKind

P.S. I miss the days when pink, green or blue dyed hair was a sign of rebellion and uniqueness, rather than a predictable trope and red flag that warns the world about all your views and opinions before you ever open your mouth. #MakeDyedHairCoolAgain

1 year ago

This one will never not be funny.

Wonder how many years discharging the gun got him.

1 year ago

"i love you" should be platonic by default and if you want to use the phrase romantically, that's on you to clarify

1 year ago

With @staff 's recent post saying 1/4 of this site is LGBTQ going around, I'd like to see what the actual demographic is

So!

Please reblog for bigger sample size!

1 year ago

So I saw a head canon for linked universe awhile, ago and I can’t get it out of my head so I’m going to share it with you all Warriors is sprit tracks link and I love that idea and that is now Canon for me and you cannot tell me otherwise 

1 year ago

Also, mending is supposed to be done as it wears. If you have holes you've waited too long. Before you get a hole, If you take old jeans and use the materials to line the inside of the problem areas in your jeans you can sew along the seams and it's not visible.

"Don't just throw ripped jeans away, you can repair them using these 10 cute Visible Mending techniques!!" unfortunately my friend the first point of failure for every single pair of jeans i have owned in my life has been the Crotch and Ass. Knees: fine, cuffs: fine; but 3 years in, and all that stands between the world and my astronaut-patterned taint is 0.5µm of denim worn so thin that every squat threatens to tear it to shreds like wet toilet paper. If the Tiktok craft community could figure out a way to resurrect jeans afflicted in such a way that doesn't involve adding a whole ass buttpatch like some sort of inverse assless chaps situation then that'd be great

3 months ago

Penelope: yeah so move the bed.

Odysseus, covered in blood: honey, love of my life, my Penelope, the reason for breathing, the fuck you mean move the damn tree!

1 year ago

There's the ghost of a child playing above Bludhaven

He's a short little thing, who glows and waves around a little sword. Sometimes he has a ship, sometimes he doesn't.

The kid keeps saying that it only fits that Bludhaven be his haunt, because it has "blud" in it and his name is "Youngblood".

Also he has declared Nightwing to be his nemesis.

Nightwing loves it; he gets to have at least one day a week that's just goofing off with a kid who can't be hurt by any of his regular villains. Their "fights" are more like play dates, if he's being honest, and Youngblood is a good kid.

Sometimes he's swinging from the sails of the kids ghost ship, dodging "ecto blasts", other times he's "teaming up" with Youngblood and "sword fights" another spectral Hero, called Phantom.

Generally, they all have a good time.

Until one day, he stumbles across some men in white suits actually managing to hurt the ghost child.

That day, the GIW learns that the most violent Robin wasn't the second one, but the first.

6 months ago
tarume - Untitled
tarume - Untitled
  • brave-blake-belladonna
    brave-blake-belladonna liked this · 4 months ago
  • totally-not-one-of-the-fae
    totally-not-one-of-the-fae liked this · 5 months ago
  • hiraethandmist
    hiraethandmist liked this · 5 months ago
  • herbofgraceandpeace
    herbofgraceandpeace liked this · 9 months ago
  • therockywhorerpictureshow
    therockywhorerpictureshow liked this · 11 months ago
  • mymanyfandomramblings
    mymanyfandomramblings liked this · 11 months ago
  • darthcat
    darthcat liked this · 11 months ago
  • obnoxiospotato
    obnoxiospotato liked this · 1 year ago
  • chaotic-theatrical-weaver
    chaotic-theatrical-weaver liked this · 1 year ago
  • hopesapowerfulthing
    hopesapowerfulthing liked this · 1 year ago
  • teamwhump
    teamwhump liked this · 1 year ago
  • aafangurl
    aafangurl liked this · 1 year ago
  • crazy-fandom-girl-posts
    crazy-fandom-girl-posts liked this · 1 year ago
  • tigerlilly3x7
    tigerlilly3x7 liked this · 1 year ago
  • napalm-waistcoat
    napalm-waistcoat liked this · 1 year ago
  • bladwinthegreat
    bladwinthegreat liked this · 1 year ago
  • acesexualpigeon
    acesexualpigeon liked this · 1 year ago
  • mintycrispy
    mintycrispy liked this · 1 year ago
  • buglover77
    buglover77 liked this · 1 year ago
  • uncontainedsmiles
    uncontainedsmiles liked this · 1 year ago
  • carriessketchbook
    carriessketchbook liked this · 1 year ago
  • naamoosh
    naamoosh liked this · 1 year ago
  • iamauraantaresbabe
    iamauraantaresbabe liked this · 1 year ago
  • hemeraandnyxx
    hemeraandnyxx liked this · 1 year ago
  • earlgreyentling
    earlgreyentling liked this · 1 year ago
  • kyohoke
    kyohoke liked this · 1 year ago
  • crescentwolfhunt
    crescentwolfhunt liked this · 1 year ago
  • pins-and-flowers
    pins-and-flowers liked this · 1 year ago
  • mintmarzipan
    mintmarzipan liked this · 1 year ago
  • liopleurodean
    liopleurodean reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • lorriecorrie
    lorriecorrie liked this · 1 year ago
  • tinyangel-of-light
    tinyangel-of-light liked this · 1 year ago
  • calicocoffee101
    calicocoffee101 liked this · 1 year ago
  • waterlilyann
    waterlilyann liked this · 1 year ago
  • aryael08
    aryael08 liked this · 1 year ago
  • thetreasurechest
    thetreasurechest liked this · 1 year ago
  • cat-dragoness
    cat-dragoness reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • ben10psy
    ben10psy liked this · 1 year ago
  • thepan04
    thepan04 liked this · 1 year ago
  • lovertrackone
    lovertrackone liked this · 1 year ago
  • graynorse
    graynorse liked this · 1 year ago
  • yorunokatana
    yorunokatana reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • yorunokatana
    yorunokatana liked this · 1 year ago
  • people-exist
    people-exist reblogged this · 1 year ago
tarume - Untitled
Untitled

189 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags