The Greek Interpreter

The Greek Interpreter
The Greek Interpreter

The Greek Interpreter

More Posts from Tworiversblog and Others

6 months ago

One area where I feel like ACD's Holmes differs from modern interpretations is the degree of Holmes' lack of empathy. He is certainly eccentric, single-minded and arrogant in the books, but he does not come across as uncaring or unkind.

To me it seems that in modern characterisations (including fanfiction), he often comes across as if he doesn't understand other people's emotions, or has no regard for them. But this is not at all true in the books.

Just as an example, in "The Sign of the Four" he asks Watson if he's up for a six-mile track, and even after Watson confirms, Holmes asks again if it might give Watson's injured leg any trouble. There are also other examples where he does display appropriate empathy when speaking to an upset client, and so on. The characterisation is more nuanced here.


Tags
7 months ago
THE ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES
THE ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES

THE ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES

2.06 The Final Problem

7 months ago
The Shore - Barry McGlashan , 2023.

The Shore - Barry McGlashan , 2023.

British, b. 1974 -

Oil on paper over panel , 12 1/4 x 8 1/8 in.

7 months ago

Rereading some of the original stories to try and help my current writer's block, and I rediscover this little gem.

Rereading Some Of The Original Stories To Try And Help My Current Writer's Block, And I Rediscover This

Sherlock Holmes saying, "doggy".

7 months ago
Some Of These Holmes Stories Honestly Are The Fanfic Equivalent Of When An Algebra Textbook Goes “solution

Some of these Holmes stories honestly are the fanfic equivalent of when an Algebra textbook goes “solution is trivial and left as an exercise for the reader”

7 months ago
Knit Vests // Frankie Print Co
Knit Vests // Frankie Print Co

Knit Vests // Frankie Print Co

7 months ago
THAT'S HOLMES RIGHT??? IN HIS BOOKSELLER DISGUISE ON THE LEFT???? THAT'S THEM WALKING IN TOGETHER SIDE

THAT'S HOLMES RIGHT??? IN HIS BOOKSELLER DISGUISE ON THE LEFT???? THAT'S THEM WALKING IN TOGETHER SIDE BY SIDE RIGHT?!!?!? JESUS CHRIST?????

7 months ago
— Virginia Woolf
— Virginia Woolf
— Virginia Woolf

— Virginia Woolf

7 months ago
Text from the Sherlock Holmes short story "The Three Students," reading "My friend's temper had not improved since he had been deprived of the congenial surroundings of Baker Street. Without his scrapbooks, his chemicals, and his homely untidiness, he was an uncomfortable man."

he's so me

8 months ago

The thing about every modern Sherlock Holmes story is that it doesn’t understand that “disdain for the existing criminal justice system” is not only a fundamental part of the themes of the ACD stories it’s vital to making the whole concept work.

Holmes, when we first meet him, is on the bleeding edge of forensics for the 1880s, and this continues on into the ‘90s (the planted thumbprint in ‘The Norwood Builder’! the Sherlock Holmes test for hemoglobin in A Study in Scarlet! the use of pigs as substitute cadavers in ‘Black Peter’!) and beyond. He’s flippant about and disrespectful toward the police because he knows how criminology is a science and forensics matter and the cold hard facts are significantly more important than intimidating witnesses to extract coerced confessions, or deciding on a theory and bending the facts to make them fit, or relying on racist stereotypes to explain how people act and who’s most guilty (all things that really happen in the canon, btw). He’s smarter than everyone else because he’s doing things no one else understands yet, he’s made a study of crime and he understands how and why policing is a flawed institution.

This is why he’s not a cop, only occasionally allied with cops, and so often complaining or explaining that a moral injustice and a legal one are two different things. There are multiple antagonists (Sir George in ‘The Beryl Coronet’, Charles Augustus Milverton, Dr. Roylott, the parents in ‘A Case of Identity’) who he can’t catch in the jaws of the law but wishes he could, and at least one criminal he overlooks because he knows prison would only force them deeper into crime.

But. But.

In the 21st century, forensics are not only the backbone of police investigation they’re common knowledge to any average police procedural enjoyer or true crime fan. Holmes’s once-cutting-edge chemistry and geology are passé and ordinary now. If he’s going to be smart, he’s got to be looking ahead.

And what does that look like? It looks like knowing about the flaws in forensic analysis, like knowing about fingerprints maybe not being totally unique, like arguing over DNA evidence being misinterpreted and innocent people being sentenced for crimes they didn’t commit, like calling for the defunding and dissembling of police forces, like siding with the underclasses every. single. time.

Holmes shouldn’t be working with the cops, he should be trying to destroy them, and fighting to prove why they’re obsolete with science and quick thinking and research. Not doing that is spitting in the face of his roots and missing the whole point of what he’s working for.


Tags
  • superjarg
    superjarg reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • skedazzle
    skedazzle liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • lestradelurkshere
    lestradelurkshere liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • superjarg
    superjarg liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • amypihcs
    amypihcs reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • violetjedisylveon
    violetjedisylveon reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • violetjedisylveon
    violetjedisylveon liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • mondwein
    mondwein liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • loveforjeremybrett
    loveforjeremybrett reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • loveforjeremybrett
    loveforjeremybrett liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • mr-nauseam
    mr-nauseam liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • mollylenore
    mollylenore reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • mollylenore
    mollylenore liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • maslickonachlebik
    maslickonachlebik liked this · 1 month ago
  • raingoddess214
    raingoddess214 liked this · 1 month ago
  • nichristi
    nichristi reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • nichristi
    nichristi liked this · 1 month ago
  • poppypirate
    poppypirate reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • fastenyourseatbelts
    fastenyourseatbelts liked this · 2 months ago
  • to-teh-world
    to-teh-world liked this · 2 months ago
  • isdwhp
    isdwhp liked this · 2 months ago
  • poeticallydisgraced
    poeticallydisgraced liked this · 2 months ago
  • strangerextime
    strangerextime liked this · 3 months ago
  • amelia1976
    amelia1976 liked this · 3 months ago
  • kenilworth-for-a-queen
    kenilworth-for-a-queen reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • kenilworth-for-a-queen
    kenilworth-for-a-queen liked this · 3 months ago
  • ilikebikestvt-blog
    ilikebikestvt-blog liked this · 3 months ago
  • reversednix
    reversednix liked this · 4 months ago
  • missmarianne
    missmarianne liked this · 4 months ago
  • jasperthecat168
    jasperthecat168 liked this · 4 months ago
  • greencarnation16
    greencarnation16 reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • greencarnation16
    greencarnation16 liked this · 4 months ago
  • timothy06-24
    timothy06-24 reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • timothy06-24
    timothy06-24 liked this · 4 months ago
  • mouse-of-mischief
    mouse-of-mischief liked this · 4 months ago
  • moroniccats
    moroniccats reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • unclassyfied404
    unclassyfied404 liked this · 4 months ago
  • meisjane8o8lantern
    meisjane8o8lantern liked this · 4 months ago
  • pyrrhicvictor-blogging
    pyrrhicvictor-blogging liked this · 5 months ago
  • invidiosa
    invidiosa reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • bermudcircle
    bermudcircle liked this · 5 months ago
  • calicomagecat
    calicomagecat liked this · 5 months ago
  • cryptidteaparty
    cryptidteaparty liked this · 6 months ago
  • nastyastar1600
    nastyastar1600 liked this · 6 months ago
  • cantwearhats
    cantwearhats liked this · 6 months ago
  • snapback-gravity-falls
    snapback-gravity-falls liked this · 6 months ago
  • mercifulheavens
    mercifulheavens liked this · 6 months ago
  • invidiosa
    invidiosa liked this · 6 months ago
  • infinemmonstrum
    infinemmonstrum liked this · 6 months ago
tworiversblog - wondering...
wondering...

32 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags