people love imagining that they’d cope with severe disabilities so much better than the people who have them do. they love feigning grace and patience and wisdom over life-or-death issues that have effected them so little, or not at all, that they can’t even name them.
my favorite tho is the classic “If I was quadriplegic I’d just kill myself” why don’t you just do it now? if life is so easily thrown away for you, why wait? do you honestly think you’re more valuable than anyone with a spinal cord injury? why? why should we believe your value system? is it based on anything but your feelings?
May I also add:
Jon hasn't internalized he can trust Martin because of season 2 behavior, delirium, flashbacks, amnesia, etc. and he has to learn to trust the gut feeling telling him that Martin is safe
obsessed with hurt/comfort fics where martin attempts to comfort jon like how someone would try and coax a spooked cat down from a tree
Think about it.
A brain in a jar would be desperately wanting some of that sweet sweet dopamine. Anyone would be craving stimulation if they had been babysitting cryopods for hundreds of years with no way to self-deactivate.
We also know from watching Brain-On-A-Roomba that he's distractible and not very able to interact with the world.
Ergo,
baby sensory video
Did you just redact the J O H N spelling of the Archivist's name?
this was so funny
Absolutely! I'm so excited for you to see what I have in the fic!
The only things my story concept would keep would be the idea of an immortal, regenerative person being exploited over generations. It would be taking place in a different country, with different characters, different cultures, different symbolism and themes, and so on. I wouldn't reuse any of your dialogue, setting, or situations.
(I even invented different injuries because I wanted to go grosser than I did in "Seven Days", lol.)
I hope this eases any concerns you have about the direction I wanted to go. If you have any other questions or concerns, please let me know! The premise of Jon as a magical being inspired me so much and the last thing I want to do would be to detract anything from a writer like yourself.
Writing based on the Magic Shop has been a wonderful exercise and I look forward to finishing my fic. One of the commenters inspired me to novelize the story, set in an original context unconnected to TMA. I have some story notes and outlines already done, though no solid plans. If I were to pursue that, what kind of credit would you want?
I appreciate you asking, but I don't really feel comfortable with you turning something based on my work into an original piece. Fanfiction is one thing because we're all playing in the same space and you can link directly back to my story hosted on the same website, but when it's original fiction it becomes disconnected from my work and owned by you. Especially considering around half of your story so far is a retelling of mine, it crosses a line for me that my work and plotline would be used for your original work.
I have really loved getting to read your fanfic, and I think you have a lot of super creative original ideas in there. If you wanted to write an original piece following the backstory of Jon you came up with, for example, that would be super cool and not lifted from anything I've written. But I'd appreciate it if you'd leave out anything including the plot of the Magic Shop, and that specific world I've written.
Additionally, I've considered turning my own story into an original piece someday, and if you did publish your own I'd lose the ability to take claim of my own story.
I hope you understand and I can't wait to read the rest of your story!!!!
Off topic, but how did you decide how old the Archivist was?
I got obsessed with "The Magic Shop" and I'm working on a fic inspired by it! Could I ask a couple of questions about the last chapter? First, did you have something in mind that Jon/Kit whispers in Angela's ear? Second, does the line "He... turned back into the room, rushing back up to Martin’s side and pushing the book into the center of HIS chest" mean Jon's or Martin's chest? PS, congratulations on making the fic stream!
Oh my gosh I’m so glad you liked it!!! And ahhh the fic stream 😂 I was overjoyed to hear them read not one but TWO of my story fragments, and yet my soul will never recover from hearing Jonny and Alex spend five full minutes calling me horny over and over again
Assigned as the horniest in the fandom by the fuckin writers. I’ll never live it down 😂
But yes! Your questions! I did not have an official idea in mind of what Jon whispered into Angela’s ear. That last chapter and final scene especially underwent a lot of heavy edits because I was having a hard time making whatever Jon did to Angela have the impact I wanted. In the end, the decision to have him whisper in her ear inaudibly was a lil bit of a work around. Came out cool and badass without me needing to figure out what that would look like 😅 BUT what I generally imagine him saying and what I was TRYING to make work in the scene is something like:
“The world may deserve magic, but you deserve *nothing*.”
Second question is easier to answer! The intention was he pushes it into Martin’s chest, like a child demanding a bedtime story 💕
I hope this helps!!! I’m SO excited that you’re inspired enough by the story to write something. I love this universe and I had some tentative plans to write spin-offs myself but I never figured out what story I’d want to tell, so I’m so so glad that someone else will help it live on.
Please link it to the original story and send it to me on here so I can read it when it’s done!!!
"children need all the support and protection and thus have no right to make any of their own decisions for their own safety"
and
"adults have the right to do whatever they want but also if they still live with their families or uses government support, they are freeloaders and lazy"
leads to
"people with cognitive disabilities are all actually children trapped in adult bodies"
and
"people with cognitive disabilities' imput on decisons about their medical care, living situations, and future isn't actually what's best for them because they don't know what is good for themselves"
disabled adults are not children, but the rights and freedoms of abled children and disabled adults are intertwined
I have DID and will beta for anyone who wants to write this
Every now and again I think about Jon having dissociative identity disorder and I think that just needs to happen. Please he has the childhood trauma for it (Im not talking about Mr Spider I mean his grandmother and parents deaths). I fucking need this. For me specifically and noone else
USER FLOWERS UNDERGROUND IN THE FIRST EPISODE. DAISY LITERALLY GOT STUCK IN THE BURIED. OH MY GOD.
touch-starvation needs to be written with emphasis on the starving part. you are hungry to be touched. so hungry that even the very taste of it makes you nauseous. it has been long since anything has ever touched you, ever fed you - that your body has grown more used to that gnawing emptiness more than anything else. it's better for you to be held, to eat but it makes you sick to try. you know
Oh goodness, I'm so excited! I have most of it written, but no specific update schedule in mind. I'll definitely send you the link when I drop the first chapter.
I got obsessed with "The Magic Shop" and I'm working on a fic inspired by it! Could I ask a couple of questions about the last chapter? First, did you have something in mind that Jon/Kit whispers in Angela's ear? Second, does the line "He... turned back into the room, rushing back up to Martin’s side and pushing the book into the center of HIS chest" mean Jon's or Martin's chest? PS, congratulations on making the fic stream!
Oh my gosh I’m so glad you liked it!!! And ahhh the fic stream 😂 I was overjoyed to hear them read not one but TWO of my story fragments, and yet my soul will never recover from hearing Jonny and Alex spend five full minutes calling me horny over and over again
Assigned as the horniest in the fandom by the fuckin writers. I’ll never live it down 😂
But yes! Your questions! I did not have an official idea in mind of what Jon whispered into Angela’s ear. That last chapter and final scene especially underwent a lot of heavy edits because I was having a hard time making whatever Jon did to Angela have the impact I wanted. In the end, the decision to have him whisper in her ear inaudibly was a lil bit of a work around. Came out cool and badass without me needing to figure out what that would look like 😅 BUT what I generally imagine him saying and what I was TRYING to make work in the scene is something like:
“The world may deserve magic, but you deserve *nothing*.”
Second question is easier to answer! The intention was he pushes it into Martin’s chest, like a child demanding a bedtime story 💕
I hope this helps!!! I’m SO excited that you’re inspired enough by the story to write something. I love this universe and I had some tentative plans to write spin-offs myself but I never figured out what story I’d want to tell, so I’m so so glad that someone else will help it live on.
Please link it to the original story and send it to me on here so I can read it when it’s done!!!