As "Rebecca das Musical" connoisseurs™, @edgyparrot and I cooked something up.
We've seen a lot of different versions (never enough) and now we're basically deciding who's best at the characters and putting them in one dream cast.
Ich: Nienke Latten (only from the Wilemijn cast, not with Mark)
Maxim de Winter: Jan Ammann
Mrs Danvers: Pia Douwes (@edgyparrot's love)
Beatrice Lacy: Kerstin Ibald (my love)
Giles Lacy: Raphael Dörr
Frank Crawley: Jörg Neubauer (the chemistry with Jan, omg)
Jack Favell: Hannes Staffler/ Mark Seibert (I know he's theoretically never played Jack, but he basically plays Maxim how I imagine Jack to be, and let's be honest, he would slay)
Ben: Daniele Nonnis
Mrs van Hopper: Isabel Dörfler (our queen <3)
Frith: Matthias Graf
Robert: (forgot his name, will look it up later)
Clarice: Christina Patten
We'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments (but accept no criticism :))