Honestly Duke wanting Eulalie to be the bait is kinda dumb when pluto is right there. He's small, fast, and has quick reactions in times of danger making him the best bait in their situation.
Duke didn't chose pluto because he cares about him more than he does for Eulalie; he doesn't want pluto to be in danger or be hurt but he wouldn't care as much if it's Eulalie who was in danger and got hurt.
At the end of the day pluto is more his friend than Eulalie is
Nevermore art dump★
My nevermore s2 predictions
Biblically accurate eulalie
(AND AMAZING ART)
This one was suggested by @therabbitreaper It is Baku
Rip eulalie you would have loved sam and colby
Rip prospero you would have HATED covid
Rip will you would have related to basil hallward
Rip annabel you would have loved chess.com
Rip ada you would have loved royal high
Rip berenice you would have loved my babysitters a vampire
Rip lenore you would have loved drag
Rip montresor you needed therapy
Rip duke you would have loved workplace safety laws
Rip pluto you would have loved the furry fandom
Rip morella you would have loved a break from ada